Manufacturing

Contractors vs Employees: who do I need to pay superannuation to?

As an employer, one of the most important factors to keep in mind with regard to the engagement of contractors is ensuring that you get the on-costs right.  The rules for superannuation, payroll tax and workers compensation are complicated, not only due to the general uncertainty surrounding the tests used to classify workers as either employees or contractors, or the grab bag of considerations to be taken into account, but also thanks to the fact that legislation in each area prescribes different exceptions or extensions to those rules.

With regard to superannuation, it is common to see situations where an individual has been engaged as a contractor, and the principal has made the assumption that as it is not an employment relationship, superannuation is not payable.  This is not always correct.

Superannuation legislation extends the definition of an ’employee’ to cover a person who works under a contract either “wholly or principally for the labour of the person”.  A worker will fit within this test and be classed as an employee (for whom superannuation is payable), even if both parties treat the connection as a contracting relationship, where the individual is renumerated for their personal labour and skills, must perform the contractual work personally (i.e. the worker has no right of delegation), and is not paid to achieve a ‘result’.

Within the context of a ‘results’ contract, the worker is likely to be paid a fixed amount for a task (as opposed to receiving compensation through an hourly, or time-based rate of pay), is required to produce a specific result, and in turn bears the risk of rectification or rework.  It therefore follows that a contractor who is both engaged on a regular open-ended basis and paid by the hour is unlikely to be on a ‘results’ contract – meaning that superannuation will be payable.

The situation is different if the contracting party is an external company responsible for supplying the services of an individual (e.g. a recruitment agency), as under this circumstance it would be the contracting/employing company that has the obligation to pay the worker’s superannuation.

So, when engaging an individual as a contractor, it is important for employers to put careful consideration towards any potential liabilities surrounding superannuation, and if necessary, to factor any relevant superannuation remittances into the payments being made to the contractor.
By doing so, employers can ensure that they forego any nasty surprises by way of liability for superannuation, interest and/or possible penalties when the relationship sours or comes to an end.

For further information relating to the classification of workers as either employees or contractors, please see Coleman Greig’s Plain English Guide to Employee or Contractor.

If you have a query relating to any of the information in this article, or you would like to speak with an experienced employment lawyer with regard to contracting relationships and/or on-costs, please get in touch with Coleman Greig’s Employment Law team today.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes only and is not a substitute for legal advice. For more details, please read our full disclaimer.

Share:

Send an enquiry

Any personal information you provide is collected pursuant to our Privacy Policy.

Categories
Archives
Author

More posts

Strata Reforms in NSW – 2026 Edition

New NSW strata reforms from 1 April 2026 introduce updated requirements for documentation, governance and transparency across strata schemes.

Business people shaking hands, finishing up a meeting.
Joint venture vs. partnership

Joint venture or partnership? We explain the differences and highlight the pros and cons of each structure.

A woman works from home. She's sitting at a desk with a Christmas tree in the background
Employment arrangements during the holiday season break

Many businesses will be preparing for a shutdown period over the upcoming holiday season break. Earlier this year, standardised shutdown provisions were inserted into the majority of modern awards. These covered how you could direct employees to take annual leave or unpaid leave during an annual shutdown

Year-end land tax and foreign surcharge – What you need to know

With 31 December 2025 fast approaching, if you have not done so already, we encourage you to review/double check your property arrangements and documentation. Assessments for land tax and foreign surcharge are issued around this time, and understanding your obligations now can help you avoid unexpected liabilities.

© 2026 Coleman Greig Lawyers  |  Sitemap  |  Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. ABN 73 125 176 230