A man in a grey business shirt looks sideways. Someone has placed a hand over his mouth.

Employers Beware: If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all

Stephen Booth ||

Over the last few years we have seen a significant spike in defamation litigation, much of which seems to have been prompted by careless comments made either via email or on social media platforms.  One recent example which demonstrates the risk within an employment law context is the case of Bowden v KSMC Holdings Pty Ltd t/as Hubba Bubba Childcare on Haig & Chapman [2019] NSWDC 98 (4 April 2019).

Matthew Bowden, the Plaintiff in this matter, worked for the Hubba Bubba Childcare Centre in Chatswood.  He was a young employee, in his first childcare job, working part time while studying to attain his childcare qualifications.  Ms Chapman, the Director and Manager of the centre and one of the Defendants in this matter, became difficult when Mr Bowden could not work the hours that she requested of him due to his study commitments.

As a result of Ms Chapman’s difficult behaviour, Mr Bowden reluctantly gave notice and resigned from his employment – although prior to the notice period coming to an end, Ms Chapman had Mr Bowden escorted from the premises, in front of a group of parents.

Soon after this incident, Ms Champan emailed 35 parents, saying:

“Matt – is unfortunately no longer with us due to disciplinary reasons.  Whilst being good with children in general, Matt was not truthful with us regarding his studies and some other issues and I thought it was better for him to move on and possibly gain a bit more life experience”.

Mr Bowden became aware of the email sent to parents, and was deeply hurt by the negative comments, which the District Court subsequently found to be entirely untrue: Mr Bowden had not misled Ms Chapman about his qualifications, and there had been no valid disciplinary reasons for his departure.

Mr Bowden sued Ms Chapman for defamation and won.  Ms Chapman was an evasive and argumentative witness, which undoubtedly damaged her credibility.  It was noted by the court that Ms Chapman had withheld payment due to Mr Bowden for wages and his notice period, and that she had also pursued him, without good grounds, for a negative review of the centre which she speculated that he had posted to Google.  In addition, Ms Chapman had refused to apologise for the defamatory emails when asked to do so.

The court found that Mr Bowden had not been dismissed for dishonesty, but that he had in fact resigned.  Similarly, it was found that he had not been dishonest, and that he had not been given any opportunity to respond to the alleged dishonesty.

In circumstances where it was quite possible for an early apology to have avoided the whole case, Mr Bowden was awarded damages and interest of more than $230,000, plus legal costs for an 11-day hearing.

In my opinion, it would’ve been wise for Ms Chapman to heed the old adage of good manners:  “If you can’t say anything nice, then don’t say anything at all”.  Sending a defamatory message by email or social media vastly increases the risk of a claim, and provides concrete evidence of both what was said, and how widely it was communicated.

Even when providing a reference, with a much more limited circulation, it is wise for employers to be circumspect and factual in what they say, and not take the opportunity to vent.

If you have a query relating to any of the information in this piece, or you would like to speak with a lawyer in Coleman Greig’s Employment Law team with regard to a matter of your own, please don’t hesitate to get in touch today:


Send an enquiry

Any personal information you provide is collected pursuant to our Privacy Policy.


More posts

Understanding roles in the strata scheme

A strata scheme is a building or group of buildings that have been divided into lots which can be apartments, villas, offices, units or townhouses. This will be articulated in the strata plan.

Can i put my home on Airbnb?

Airbnb is a form of short-term rental accommodation. To add your property to Airbnb in NSW, you are required to meet several laws and regulations governing short-term rentals.

When are liquidators required to seek approval to retain legal counsel?

When does a liquidator (or the company he or she is appointed to) need court, creditor, or committee approval to validly retain a solicitor to act in a liquidation matter which is likely to extend for longer than three months?  The answer to this question has only recently been settled.

Proposed changes to building and construction law in NSW

The Building Bill 2022 (the Bill) is the key avenue through which the NSW Government has proposed to reshape the culture of the building and construction industry by eliminating poor performance and improving the quality of building statewide.

Can you dismiss an employee who fails to return to the office?

Slowly but surely, most employers are requiring employees to return to the office for at least a portion of their working week. Some employers continue to struggle with employees resistant to returning to the office or those who have an expectation that they can continue to work from home whenever it suits them.

New powers to combat phoenixing in construction

The rise of phoenixing in the building and construction industry in Australia in recent years has proved a significant challenge to regulators. Mismanagement of time or cashflow can quickly propel businesses into insolvency.

The NSW Building Commission’s extraordinary powers

In late 2023, the NSW Government passed the Building Legislation Amendment Bill 2023 (Amendment Bill). The Amendment Bill established the NSW Building Commission and granted it extraordinary powers to enter construction sites, inspect work and take away information and materials.

© 2024 Coleman Greig Lawyers   |  Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. ABN 73 125 176 230