In the Modern Corporate Office Meeting Room: Diverse Group of Businesspeople, Lawyers, Executives and Members of the Board of Directors Talking, Negotiating and Working on a Winning Strategy.

Defining Managerial and Directorial Roles and Can These Employees Make Unfair Dismissal Claims?

This blog takes a look at a number of factors that must be considered when trying to define a managerial, or directorial role within a business.  We have also taken a look at some potential issues surrounding unfair dismissal applications made by employees who are not covered by either an enterprise agreement, or an industry/occupation award.

Firstly, it is important to note that an employee is able to make an unfair dismissal claim if they are covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement.  Employees not covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement are able to make an unfair dismissal claim, although this is only if they earn less than the high income threshold, which is currently set at $142,000 (NB: this amount is subject to change as it is indexed from year to year).

In determining whether or not a person is legally covered by an award, it is necessary to consider their position in its entirety, that is, not only the employee’s job title but their associated duties, as well as the principle purpose of the position.  Focusing solely on an employee’s title (or even their associated remuneration) can be both deceptive and hazardous for an employer caught up in an unfair dismissal claim.

By way of example, ordinarily one might assume that an employee holding the position of ‘Manager’ or ‘Director’ would not be covered by an award, particularly if their salary exceeds the high income threshold.  With that said, in the recent case of Karen Muscat v Chase Commercials Pty Limited T/A Chase Commercials [2018] FWC 1398, heard before the Fair Work Commission, this assumption proved to be very wrong.

In this case, the employee’s title with Chase Commercial was ‘Director of Asset Management’ and her salary was approximately $180,000, although following her termination she filed an unfair dismissal application.  The employer objected to the application on the basis that the employee was not legally eligible to make an unfair dismissal claim as she was not covered by an award, and that her salary exceed the high income threshold.

The employee argued that she was indeed covered by an award, specifically the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 (‘the Award’), and that under that award her duties clearly fell under the classification of ‘Property Management Supervisor’.  The employee further argued that her title was irrelevant, that she was simply a ‘property manager with a fancy title’ and that the objective of the fancy title was that it allowed her to mix with other owners of the same calibre.

Following an examination of the principal purpose of the employee’s position, the FWC sided with the employee and concluded that her position did fall within the classification of a ‘Property Management Supervisor’ under the Award, and that her title of ‘Director’ had not resulted in her being elevated beyond the status of an award employee.

Award classifications can often be tricky at their core, as can be determining whether an employee is eligible to make an unfair dismissal claim.  If you have any doubts or concerns with regard to either of these issues, or would simply like to speak with an experienced lawyer in our Employment Law team – please do not hesitate to contact us.


Send an enquiry

Any personal information you provide is collected pursuant to our Privacy Policy.


More posts

SafeWork NSW
SafeWork NSW releases new strategy to address psychosocial hazards

On 22 May 2024 SafeWork NSW introduced a new strategy to address psychological and psychosocial hazards. The SafeWork NSW Psychological Health and Safety Strategy 2024-2026 establishes new supports for employers regarding their duties in preventing psychosocial harm in the workplace.

roles in the strata scheme
Understanding roles in the strata scheme

A strata scheme is a building or group of buildings that have been divided into lots which can be apartments, villas, offices, units or townhouses. This will be articulated in the strata plan.

Airbnb home
Can I put my home on Airbnb?

Airbnb is a form of short-term rental accommodation. To add your property to Airbnb in NSW, you are required to meet several laws and regulations governing short-term rentals.

liquidators required to seek approval
When are liquidators required to seek approval to retain legal counsel?

When does a liquidator (or the company he or she is appointed to) need court, creditor, or committee approval to validly retain a solicitor to act in a liquidation matter which is likely to extend for longer than three months?  The answer to this question has only recently been settled.

Proposed changes to building
Proposed changes to building and construction law in NSW

The Building Bill 2022 (the Bill) is the key avenue through which the NSW Government has proposed to reshape the culture of the building and construction industry by eliminating poor performance and improving the quality of building statewide.

Dismiss an employee
Can you dismiss an employee who fails to return to the office?

Slowly but surely, most employers are requiring employees to return to the office for at least a portion of their working week. Some employers continue to struggle with employees resistant to returning to the office or those who have an expectation that they can continue to work from home whenever it suits them.

Phoenixing in Construction
New powers to combat phoenixing in construction

The rise of phoenixing in the building and construction industry in Australia in recent years has proved a significant challenge to regulators. Mismanagement of time or cashflow can quickly propel businesses into insolvency.

© 2024 Coleman Greig Lawyers  |  Sitemap  |  Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. ABN 73 125 176 230